Internet Engineering Steering Group (iesg)

Internet Engineering Steering Group (iesg)
Internet Engineering Steering Group (iesg)
About
Meetings
Working Groups
Statements
Appeals
History
Photos
Email expansions
IESG Appeals
Date
Appeal
2026-01-16
Complaint to IESG regarding a declaration of consensus to adopt a non-hybrid draft (Daniel J. Bernstein)
Appeal - 2026-01-16
IESG Follow-up - 2026-01-20
Response - 2026-03-12
2025-11-24
Complaint to IESG regarding censorship of dissent (Daniel J. Bernstein)
Appeal v1 - 2025-11-24
Appeal v2 - 2025-11-24
IESG Follow-up - 2025-12-11
Response - 2026-03-12
2025-10-15
Complaint to IESG regarding AD decision (Daniel J. Bernstein)
Appeal - 2025-10-15
IESG Follow-up - 2025-10-24 - 2025-10-24
Response - 2025-10-31
2025-08-27
Complaint regarding censorship of MODPOD list (Daniel J. Bernstein)
Appeal correspondence and text contents - 2025-08-27
Appeal PDF - 2025-08-27
Response - 2025-10-17
2025-08-12
Complaint regarding a declaration of consensus to adopt a non-hybrid draft (D. J. Bernstein)
Appeal correspondence and text contents - 2025-08-12
Appeal PDF - 2025-08-12
Response - 2025-10-01
2025-06-17
Appeal to the forwarding of draft-ietf-lsr-igp-ureach-prefix-announce (Aijun Wang)
Appeal - 2025-06-17
Response - 2025-09-08
2025-05-01
Complaint regarding BCP 79 violations in the LAMPS WG (D. J. Bernstein)
Appeal correspondence and text contents - 2025-05-01
Appeal PDF - 2025-05-01
Response - 2025-05-22
2025-02-20
Appeal Re: Complaint regarding threat (D. J. Bernstein)
Appeal - 2025-02-20
Response - 2025-03-18
2024-12-15
Appeal regarding threat on the TLS Mailing List (D. J. Bernstein)
Appeal - 2024-12-15
Response - 2025-01-09
2024-11-06
Appeal to the IESG re WGLC of draft-ietf-lsr-multi-tlv) (Aijun Wang, 2024-11-06)
Appeal - 2024-11-06
Response - 2025-01-23
2023-08-15
Appeal: IESG Statement on Guidance on In-Person and Online Interim Meetings (John Klensin, 2023-08-15)
Appeal - 2023-08-15
Response - 2023-08-24
2023-07-19
Appeal of current Guidance on in-Person and Online meetings (Ted Hardie, Alan Frindell, 2023-07-19)
Appeal - 2023-07-19
Response - 2023-08-15
2020-07-08
Appeal re: URI Scheme Application and draft-mcsweeney-drop-scheme (Tim McSweeney, 2020-07-08)
Appeal - 2020-07-08
Response - 2020-07-28
2020-04-22
Appeal to the IESG re WGLC of draft-ietf-spring-srv6-network-programming (Fernando Gont, Andrew Alston, and Sander Steffann, 2020-04-22)
Appeal - 2020-04-23
Response - 2020-06-03
2020-02-04
Appeal re Protocol Action: 'URI Design and Ownership' to Best
Current Practice (draft-nottingham-rfc7320bis-03.txt) (John Klensin; 2020-02-04)
Appeal - 2020-02-04
Response - 2020-03-24
2018-07-07
Appeal of IESG Conflict Review process and decision on draft-mavrogiannopoulos-pkcs8-validated-parameters-02 (John Klensin; 2018-07-07)
Appeal - 2018-07-07
Response - 2018-08-16
2017-11-29
Appeal of IESG decision to defer action and request that ISE publish draft-klensin-dns-function-considerations (John Klensin; 2017-11-29)
Appeal - 2017-11-29
Response - 2017-11-30
2015-03-11
Appeal to the IESG concerning its approval of the "draft-ietf-ianaplan-icg-response" (PDF file) (JFC Morfin; 2015-03-11)
Appeal - 2015-03-11
Response - 2015-04-16
2014-08-28
Appeal re tzdist mailing list moderation (Tobias Conradi; 2014-08-28) / Withdrawn by Submitter
Appeal - 2014-08-28
2013-11-14
Appeal re draft-masotta-tftpexts-windowsize-opt (Patrick Masotta; 2013-11-14)
Appeal - 2013-11-14
Response - 2014-01-27
2013-06-19
Appeal re draft-ietf-manet-nhdp-sec-threats (Abdussalam Baryun; 2013-06-19)
Appeal - 2013-06-19
Response - 2013-07-02
2013-05-30
Appeal of decision to advance RFC6376 (Douglas Otis; 2013-05-30)
Appeal - 2013-05-30
Response - 2013-06-27
2013-04-05
Appeal to the IESG in regards to RFC 6852 (PDF file) (JFC Morfin; 2013-04-05)
Appeal - 2013-04-06
Response - 2013-04-17
2010-03-10
Appeal to the IESG concerning the approbation of the IDNA2008 document set (PDF file) (JFC Morfin; 2010-03-10)
Appeal - 2010-03-10
Response - 2010-04-07
2009-02-16
Authentication-Results Header Field Appeal (Douglas Otis, David Rand; 2009-02-16) / Withdrawn by Submitter
Appeal - 2009-02-16
2008-11-14
Appeal to the IAB of IESG rejection of Appeal to Last Call draft-ietf-grow-anycast (Dean Anderson; 2008-11-14)
Appeal - 2008-11-14
Response - 2008-12-15
2008-09-10
Appeal to the IESG Concerning the Way At Large Internet Lead Users Are Not Permitted To Adequately Contribute to the IETF Deliverables (JFC Morfin; 2008-09-10)
Appeal - 2008-09-10
Response - 2008-09-28
2008-07-28
Appeal over suspension of posting rights for Todd Glassey (Todd Glassey; 2008-07-28)
Appeal - 2008-07-28
Response - 2008-09-02
2008-06-13
Appeal against IESG blocking DISCUSS on draft-klensin-rfc2821bis (John C Klensin; 2008-06-13)
Appeal - 2008-06-14
Response - 2008-07-07
2007-12-26
Appeal: Continued Abuse of Process by IPR-WG Chair (Dean Anderson; 2007-12-26)
Appeal - 2007-12-26
Response - 2008-01-15
2007-11-26
Appeal to the IESG from Todd Glassey (Todd Glassey; 2007-11-26)
Appeal - 2007-11-26
Response - 2008-01-23
2007-06-22
Appeal Against the Removal of the Co-Chairs of the GEOPRIV Working Group (PDF file) (Randall Gellens, Allison Mankin, and Andrew Newton; 2007-06-22)
Appeal - 2007-06-23
Response - 2007-09-20
2006-10-24
Appeal concerning the WG-LTRU rechartering (JFC Morfin; 2006-10-24)
Appeal - 2006-10-24
Response - 2006-11-07
2006-09-09
Appeal against decision within July 10 IESG appeal dismissal (JFC Morfin; 2006-09-09)
Appeal - 2006-09-09
Response - 2006-09-15
2006-08-29
Appeal: Mandatory to implement HTTP authentication mechanism in the Atom Publishing Protocol (Robert Sayre; 2006-08-29)
Appeal - 2006-08-29
Response - 2006-10-16
2006-08-16
Appeal Against IESG Decisions Regarding the draft-ietf-ltru-matching (PDF file) (JFC Morfin; 2006-08-16)
Appeal - 2006-08-16
Response - 2006-08-22
Response - 2006-11-07
2006-06-14
Amended Appeal Re: grow: Last Call: 'Operation of Anycast Services' to BCP (draft-ietf-grow-anycast) (Dean Anderson; 2006-06-14)
Appeal - 2006-06-14
Response - 2006-07-10
2006-05-17
Appeal Against an IESG Decision Denying Me IANA Language Registration Process by way of PR-Action (PDF file) (JFC Morfin; 2006-05-17)
Appeal - 2006-05-17
Response - 2006-07-10
2006-03-08
Appeal to the IESG of PR-Action against Dean Anderson (Dean Anderson; 2006-03-08)
Appeal - 2006-03-08
Response - 2006-03-20
2006-02-20
Appeal to IESG against AD decision: one must clear the confusion opposing the RFC 3066 Bis consensus (JFC Morfin; 2006-02-20)
Appeal - 2006-02-20
Response - 2006-03-06
2006-02-17
Appeal to the IESG of an IESG decision (JFC Morfin; 2006-02-17)
Appeal - 2006-02-17
Response - 2006-07-10
2006-02-07
Appeal to the IESG in reference to the ietf-languages@alvestrand.no mailing list (JFC Morfin; 2006-02-07)
Appeal - 2006-02-08
Response - 2006-02-22
2006-01-14
Appeal to the IESG against an IESG decision concerning RFC 3066 Bis Draft (JFC Morfin; 2006-01-14)
Appeal - 2006-01-14
Response - 2006-02-21
2005-10-19
Appeal over a key change in a poor RFC 3066 bis example (JFC Morfin; 2005-10-19)
Appeal - 2005-10-19
Response - 2005-11-15
2005-08-29
Additional appeal against publication of draft-lyon-senderid-* in regards to its recommended use of Resent- header fields in the way that is inconsistant with RFC2822(William Leibzon; 2005-08-29)
Appeal - 2005-08-29
Response - 2005-12-08
2005-08-25
Appeal: Publication of draft-lyon-senderid-core-01 in conflict with referenced draft-schlitt-spf-classic-02 (Julian Mehnle; 2005-08-25)
Appeal - 2005-08-24
Response - 2005-12-08
2005-06-10
Appeal of decision to standardize "Mapping Between the Multimedia Messaging Service (MMS) and Internet Mail" (John C Klensin; 2005-06-10)
Appeal - 2005-06-10
Response - 2005-07-22
2003-11-15
Appeal regarding IESG decision on the GROW WG (David Meyer; 2003-11-15)
Appeal - 2003-11-15
Response - 2003-11-25
2003-08-06
Appeal: Official notice of appeal on suspension rights (Todd Glassey; 2003-08-06)
Appeal - 2003-08-06
Response - 2003-09-24
2003-07-31
Appeal: AD response to Site-Local Appeal (Tony Hain; 2003-07-31)
Appeal - 2003-07-31
Response - 2003-09-30
2003-01-15
Appeal against IESG decision for draft-chiba-radius-dynamic-authorization-05.txt (Glen Zorn; 2003-01-15)
Appeal - 2003-01-15
Response - 2003-02-08
2002-11-05
Appeal Against moving draft-ietf-ipngwg-addr-arch-v3 to Draft Standard (Robert Elz; 2002-11-05)
Appeal - 2002-11-05
Response - 2002-12-27